The Advisory Council
Personal Advisory Report
RE: IT Portfolio Management
Date: Apr 10 2008 3:55PM
Response by: Mary Ann McIlraith & Mark O’Gara
Question restatement:
  • What is the definition of portfolio management?
  • What is the typical job description for a portfolio manager?
  • Where does portfolio management fit within an IT organization?
  • What are some industry standard ways of measuring the value of IT portfolio elements?


  • Advice:

    What is the definition of portfolio management?

    IT portfolio management is the process of aligning investments with corporate business needs, and the analysis and proper mitigation of investment risks.  It involves the selection of work to be managed and delivered, as well as the oversight of progress against plan.

    At its most mature, IT portfolio management is accomplished through the creation of three portfolios:

    Application Portfolio - Management of this portfolio focuses on comparing spending on established systems based upon their relative value to the organization.  The comparison can be based upon the level of contribution in terms of IT investment’s profitability.  Additionally, this comparison can also be based upon the non-tangible factors such as organizations’ level of experience with a certain technology, users’ familiarity with the applications and infrastructure, and external forces such as emergence of new technologies and obsolesence of old ones.

    Project Portfolio - This aspect of portfolio management specifically addresses the issues around spending on the development of innovative capabilities, in terms of potential ROI, and on reducing investment overlaps in situations where reorganization or acquisition occurs.  The management issues with the second type of portfolio management can be judged in terms of data cleanliness, maintenance savings, suitability of resulting solution, and the relative value of new investments to replace these projects.

    Resource Portfolio Management - RPM involves analyzing and forecasting the talent that companies need to execute their business strategy, proactively rather than reactively; it is a critical strategic activity, enabling the organization to identify, develop and sustain the workforce skills it needs to successfully accomplish its strategic intent while balancing career and lifestyle goals of its employees.  RPM helps control labor costs, assess talent needs, make informed business decisions, and assess talent market risks as part of overall enterprise risk management.  RPM’s chief goal is helping companies ensure they have the right people in the right place at the right time and at the right cost.

    What is the typical job description for a portfolio manager?

    A portfolio manager’s principle duty is to act as the IT business partner for their respective business units.  The responsibilities of the portfolio manager include helping the business unit understand the total cost of ownership for their application portfolio, working with the business units to prioritize new work (projects), communicate the business value proposition for new projects to the IT organization, helping the business understand and mitigate risk, and actively managing the application portfolio.  New IT projects often fail because the business unit can not deploy the new application or enhancement.  The portfolio manager must be able to articulate the total costs associated with new projects including the impact to the business unit.  The required qualifications for a portfolio manager include project management, business process modeling, cost modeling, and the ability to integrate operational data into the application portfolio.  Outcomes for the portfolio manager are more business value for IT investments, and reduced TCO costs by eliminating legacy and duplicate applications.

    Where does portfolio management fit within an IT organization?

    The portfolio management function typically sits within the IT Progam Management Office.

    What are some of the industry standard ways of measuring the value of the following IT portfolio elements:  Systems, Assets, Services?

    There is no industry standard for measuring the value of the IT portfolio elements.  There are, however, best practices and metrics for the elements.  System key metrics are average CPU utilization, power consumption, and BTUs (amount of heat produced) as data centers become concerned with the cost of energy.  IT assets usually have financial and operation metrics associated with them, such as maintenance costs, depreciation and availability.  IT services should be defined in the service catalogue, to communicate the development and infrastructure services available to the business units.

    SmartSummary

    A major driver in the use of portfolio management is to benchmark the organizations profit, people and processes; so portfolio management and project management disciplines are consistently monitored to enhance performance and profit.  Portfolio management, project methodology, company strategic plans, budgets, projects and people should all integrate in a single source, providing the portfolio manager clarity on which projects are providing the value to the firm.

    TAC SmartGrid
    Alignment

    Portfolio Managment is a process — something one does to answer questions such as:
    1. Which projects best support the enterprise strategy?
    2. Where should the resources from a project nearing completion best be allocated?
    3. Which programs, projects, and infrastructure support efforts are currently behind schedule, over budget, etc.; why; and what should be done about them?
    4. Do we have enough of the right people to successfully take on a key initiative?
    5. How is the resource plan impacted when a new project is added to the portfolio?
    Cost Reduction

    The cost reductions from effective portfolio management will come in the following areas:
    • Reduced time to market
    • Delivering products and projects in a more rapid time-frame
    • Providing better quality and service to your clients
    • Fine-tuning the delivery model
    • Enhancing the effectiveness of the entire IT organization, people and processes
    • Leadership development embedded within a solid methodology
    • Enhanced team collaboration, productivity and skills
    • Risk and cost mitigation
    • Collaboration with your clients
    • Alignment with stakeholder vision
    Organization

    Always ensure a solid change management-transformation approach is implemented; this will enhance the delivery and acceptance of your IT governance structure.

    IT portfolio management as a systematic discipline is more applicable to larger IT organizations; in smaller organizations its concerns might be generalized into IT planning and governance as a whole.
    Technology

    There are several software vendors, such as EPK Group, Artemis, CA, Primavera and Microsoft providing software for portfolio management.  None of them have a total, integrated solution.

    Additionally, you will have to implement a solid project management methodology before setting up any of your portfolio management dashboards.  The Project Management Institute (PMI) provides theory, but not the detail tools and templates for the disciplined process.

    Maximum Potential R.I.M. provides a complete project management toolkit, and you can develop your own dashboards (PPM) in-house, which will provide you with a lower cost and a solution that is tailored to your executive and project staff needs.  [One of the authors is affiliated with Maximum Potential.]
    Sources and Referrals:

    C. Verhoef, “Quantitative IT Portfolio Management,” Science of Computer Programming 45, 2002.

    Project Management Keeps IT From Being A Victim Of Success,” InformationWeek, April 7, 2008.

    Microsoft: Optimizing Project Portfolio Management

    Oracle Project Portfolio Management

    CA Clarity PPM

    Primavera

    EPK Group

    Artemis

    Maximum Potential Rapid Implementation Methodology



    ©2002-2008 The Advisory Council, Inc. All rights reserved.